"Star Trek: Deep Space Nine" (DS9) is often regarded as one of the best sci-fi shows for several reasons that set it apart from other Star Trek series and sci-fi shows in general. Initially underrated, DS9 gradually revealed its strengths, becoming a beloved series with a dedicated following.
Serialized Storytelling:
Unlike its predecessors like "Star Trek: The Next Generation" (TNG) or the original series, DS9 embraced serialized storytelling. As well as standalone episodes with self-contained plots, DS9 introduced long-term story arcs that spanned entire seasons. This allowed for deeper exploration of characters, themes, and ongoing conflicts, making the show feel more cohesive and engaging over time. It always used to bother me that characters would hardly ever talk about what happened last week, as if the events of episodes had no effect on their current lives. True, in the early episodes of DS9, it somewhat followed this pattern of a standalone network show, but come seasons 3 and 4, the writers fully embraced what we now consider modern storytelling. I remember watching the last half of season 7 and realizing that they were ending this show in true serialized fashion in a 9-part arc that totally blew my mind. Of course, it's not only the serialized storytelling that was amazing. Some of the standalone episodes, like the simply stunning "The Visitor," are breathtaking examples of what the creative team could do on this show.
Complex Characters
DS9 featured a diverse and complex cast of characters, each with their own motivations, flaws, and moral dilemmas. Characters like Benjamin Sisko, Kira Nerys, Odo, and Quark were not simply archetypes but evolved over the series, facing personal growth and profound challenges. This depth of characterization contributed to the show's emotional impact and resonance. The kind of depth for Trek characters in DS9 was totally fresh to me. Even characters that at first didn't seem that important to the main story arc, like O'Brien and Garak, had amazing character arcs, so much so that those two characters became some of my favorites in the entire franchise.
Moral Ambiguity
While other Star Trek series often portrayed clear distinctions between right and wrong, DS9 delved into moral ambiguity and shades of gray. It explored themes of loyalty, sacrifice, the consequences of war, and the ethical dilemmas faced in political and social conflicts. This nuanced approach to storytelling provided a more realistic and thought-provoking portrayal of the Star Trek universe. Let's talk about the infamous episode "In the Pale Moonlight." The wholesome Captain Sisko starts out with cloudy but good intentions in trying to persuade the Romulan Empire to join the war against the Dominion, but ends up being involved in a literal assassination of a Romulan senator, which is then blamed on the Dominion. But here's the thing: Sisko is horrified that this could have happened and obviously regrets getting the help of a certain Cardassian tailor, but the result is that the Romulans join the war effort. Sisko does not tell the Romulans or Starfleet what has happened, as he deems this result to be for the greater good.
Political Intrigue and Realism
Set on a space station near a stable wormhole, DS9 explored political intrigue, alliances, and conflicts among various factions and civilizations. It depicted a more realistic portrayal of diplomacy and the consequences of interstellar politics, contrasting with the more idealistic views of exploration and diplomacy in other Trek shows. When this show started, the idea of a Trek show taking place anywhere but on a ship was insane. I thought I would miss visiting new planets every week, and at the start, I did. But the writers were playing the long game. The characters on the station and the ones that frequently visited were being built up and rounded out in a way TNG could only dream of.
Cultural Diversity and Exploration
DS9 delved deeply into exploring the cultures and histories of various alien species, including the Bajorans, Cardassians, Ferengi, and others. This exploration of diverse cultures added richness to the show's universe and allowed for exploration of themes such as colonialism, religious faith, and cultural identity. TNG would touch on this when they visited planets, but DS9 had the time to delve into what would make different civilizations interesting with all their complexities and differences. Of course, we cannot forget that DS9 gave us our first Black Star Trek lead in the amazing Avery Brooks. Even though he was initially held back by the silly decision to not allow him to have his beard, as it was deemed "too Black," he thrived in this role, presenting one of the best and strongest Star Trek captains yet.
Avery Brooks brought a powerful presence to the character of Captain Benjamin Sisko, breaking new ground in representation. Sisko was a multifaceted character: a dedicated Starfleet officer, a loving father, a widower, and later, a religious figure for the Bajoran people. Brooks infused Sisko with a commanding authority, warmth, and depth, making him a standout figure in the Star Trek universe.
Sisko's journey was unique compared to previous captains. His storylines often revolved around his personal growth and the complex relationships he navigated. As a single father to his son Jake, Sisko's relationship with Jake was one of the most touching aspects of the series, showcasing a strong and positive depiction of Black fatherhood rarely seen on television at the time.
Brooks' portrayal also allowed for the exploration of themes of race and identity. Episodes like "Far Beyond the Stars," where Sisko experiences life as a Black science fiction writer in the 1950s facing racism and prejudice, directly addressed issues of racial inequality and provided a powerful commentary on the struggles faced by Black individuals throughout history.
Despite the initial restrictions, Brooks' advocacy for his character's appearance led to a more authentic portrayal. When he was finally allowed to grow his beard and shave his head in later seasons, it marked a turning point for his character, symbolizing a deeper and more personal connection to Sisko's identity and heritage.
Avery Brooks' performance as Captain Sisko was groundbreaking and influential, contributing significantly to DS9's legacy and its status as one of the best sci-fi shows ever. His portrayal was a vital part of what made DS9 resonate so deeply with fans and helped pave the way for greater diversity and representation in science fiction.
DS9's departure from the traditional Star Trek format, initially discomforting, its focus on complex characters and story arcs, and its exploration of moral ambiguity and political realism have truly contributed to its reputation as one of the best sci-fi shows ever. Most importantly, it appealed not only to Star Trek fans but also to viewers interested in deep storytelling and exploration of complex themes within a science fiction setting.
Start watching the amazing Deep Space 9 by clicking below for the physical version
Or here for the new fangled digital version
Comments